What is ETL?

Extract — Transform — Load

ETL involves extracting data from source systems, transforming it into the required format in a staging area, and loading it into a target system, typically a Data Warehouse (DWH). Historically, ETL has been the predominant method, especially when the DWH lacked the processing power to handle complex transformations.


What is ELT?

Extract — Load — Transform

With ELT, data is extracted and loaded directly into the target system (usually a DWH). Transformations are then performed within the target system itself. This method leverages the powerful computing capabilities of modern data platforms (e.g., cloud-based solutions) to handle extensive transformations.

extract, transform, load vs. extract, load, transform
etl-vs-elt


ETL Process

Extraction

Raw data is collected from diverse source systems, which may include structured, semi-structured, or unstructured data such as databases, files, SaaS applications, IoT sensors, or application events. At this stage, ETL and ELT methods do not yet differ.

Loading

This step marks the primary distinction between ETL and ELT:

  • In ETL, data is first sent to an intermediate server (e.g., data warehouse) for processing.
  • In ELT, data is directly transferred to the target system (e.g., data lake), reducing latency between extraction and availability but increasing the load on the target system.

Transformation

Transformation involves structuring and standardizing raw data within a database or data warehouse. Although storage costs may increase, this step enhances capabilities for subsequent BI, data analytics, and reporting processes.

The difference between ETL and ELT

Both methods play a central role in data processing. However, their different approaches present different advantages and challenges, depending on business requirements. In the following table, we highlight the most important differences to help you find the best approach for your data strategy.

Aspect ETL ELT
Primary System The transformation takes place in an intermediate system or ETL tool. The transformation starts only in the target system (e.g., DWH).
Storage An intermediate storage layer may be used for the transformation process. Loads raw data directly into the target system and transforms it afterwards. The storage of raw data must be considered.
Use Case Historically preferred for traditional DWHs and when transformations are complex. Increasingly popular with cloud-native DWHs like Snowflake, BigQuery, and Redshift — especially when transformations can be efficiently handled by the DWH itself.
Scalability Scalability is limited by the capacity of the ETL tool and the performance of the intermediate system. Scales with the performance and capabilities of the DWH; however, cost and performance factors must be considered.
Flexibility Flexibility may be reduced due to pre-processing transformations when business requirements change. Transformations can be adjusted after loading, offering potentially higher flexibility — but possibly at the cost of increased storage requirements.

Transition from ETL to ELT

ETL has long been the standard for data integration, primarily targeting traditional data warehouses. However, rising hardware costs, growing IT demands, and delays in ad-hoc analysis have driven many organizations toward ELT.Shifting from ETL to ELT has become increasingly popular due to improved business flexibility, better scalability, and compatibility with cloud infrastructure.

Which method is better?

Both ETL and ELT effectively consolidate data to derive actionable insights. Choosing between them depends on your organization's specific requirements, such as existing network architecture, use of cloud technology, data volume, source system complexity, and budget constraints.

Photo of Thomas Howert

ETL or ELT

Have questions or need support integrating data solutions in your organization? We look forward to hearing from you.

Make your appointment now

Thomas Howert

Founder and Business Intelligence expert for over 10 years.

Discover more articles

step architecture

Data Architecture

Effective data management is essential for long-term growth in successful companies. But what exactly is data architecture, and why is it so important?

Mehr erfahren
Blue graphic of a database

Data Warehouse

A Data Warehouse is a centralized database designed to collect, transform, and aggregate structured data from various sources such as ERP systems, CRM platforms, databases, and external systems. It serves as a consistent, optimized storage hub for facilitating rapid and efficient data querying and analysis, providing a solid foundation for Business Intelligence, reporting, and analytics.

Mehr erfahren
A network of cuboids

Data Mesh

Data Mesh architecture is a decentralized Data Management approach that organizes data across individual business domains.

Mehr erfahren